A grudge shouldn’t delay Oakland’s TOD grant

18 May

At last Tuesday’s Community and Economic Development (CED) meeting, CEDA staff member Eric Angstadt told the committee that Oakland had been awarded a grant from Caltrans to do a study on transit-oriented development (TOD) along International Boulevard. The grant will reimburse Oakland for $245,000 worth of work on this project.

During a time when the Mayor and the Council are considering slashing just about every department’s budget, grants like this are a very, very good thing because it’s clear that the City does not have funds to cover any non-essential work. And it gets even better for Oakland. TransForm, an Oakland based transportation advocacy group, has offered to do the public outreach for the project, for free. This will save Oakland tens of thousands of dollars in staff time.

You might guess that CED committee members would have been jumping for joy at the sound of this. Well, most of them were, except for Larry Reid. Take a look at this video from the hearing (thanks to V Smoothe):

I can’t tell you how upset I was when I saw this. Not only was Larry Reid turning down free work, but he was turning down free work from an organization that has significant expertise on TOD and community outreach. I get it that Reid is pissed because TransForm, and many other organizations and advocates, disagreed with him on the Oakland Airport Connector, but it is entirely innapropriate for him to say that they have done nothing else in his community when he hasn’t done his research.

TransForm has been a leader on bus rapid transit, which will create faster, more reliable bus service from San Leandro, through East Oakland, to Berkeley. The highest ridership on this line right now is in East Oakland, much of it in Reid’s district. TransForm also does regional advocacy that has benefited East Oakland, like helping pass Measure VV and advocating for more transit funding from the MTC.

Besides, if he had bothered to look at TransForm’s project page for this grant, he would have seen that they intend to work with several community groups in the area. He also might have seen that the lead staff member on this project is Joel Ramos, who has deep roots in East Oakland. Before he worked at TransForm, Joel worked for the Unity Council. And my favorite part of his bio is this line: “Joel’s family referred to AC Transit as “Aunt Claire” when he was growing up, because they depended on “her” so much to get around.” I’ve worked with Joel on BRT for the past year, and I can’t think of anyone more qualified to take a lead role in outreach for this grant.

Ultimately, Ignacio De La Fuente encouraged the committee to vote by consensus to move the grant forward to the full Council, saying that issues with TransForm could be worked out later, and this item is on the consent calendar for tomorrow’s agenda. Hopefully Reid won’t pull it off the consent calendar and will realize that no other group in the area is going to do this work for free.

This project sounds pretty amazing (read the staff report for detailed info), and it would be a shame if a grudge prevented it from moving forward.

6 Responses to “A grudge shouldn’t delay Oakland’s TOD grant”

  1. JHorner May 18, 2009 at 9:22 am #

    Retaliation of this type is at least some kind of indication of TransForm’s effectiveness. The only think worse than being targeted politically is being ignored politically!

  2. Max Allstadt May 18, 2009 at 9:25 am #

    You know, I chatted with Larry Reid at the BART Board Meeting last thursday. We spoke for almost half an hour.

    I got the impression Councilman Reid actually had a pretty good understanding of where TransForm was coming from on the Airport Connector. He just had a difference of opinion, and seemed to feel like he was at risk of being tripped up or delayed at the very end of a process that he’d been involved with for many years.

    I can see how, given the circumstances, he could be frustrated and/or anxious at the CEDA meeting last week. It was two days before the BART board meeting and everybody on both sides of the Airport Connector debate was getting antsy and nervous in anticipation of a battle. The blogs were getting strident and contentious, and based on past and recent experience with the power of the BlogOaksphere, I totally can understand Mr. Reid feeling the way he did.

    I still respectfully disagree with Mr. Reid’s stance on the Airport Connector, but I think it’s unfair to presume he’s vindictive or grouchy enough to hold a permanent grudge against Transform. Larry Reid’s overall personality is anything but mean-spirited. He’s a kind man, softhearted enough that when I saw him during the Oakland Riots, he was walking the streets fearlessly putting out good vibes and trying to calm the situation down by setting an example.

    Particularly seeing as the vote at BART board went the way Mr. Reid wanted it to, I hope we will see him embrace TransForm’s role in providing free services to the City of Oakland.

    • Becks May 18, 2009 at 12:44 pm #

      Max – I didn’t assume he will hold a permanent grudge. In fact, I specifically stated that I hope he will not.

      I also want to point out that none of us, neither bloggers nor TransForm, attacked Larry Reid during the Oakland Airport Connector debate. In fact, I stood up for him at a community meeting about the issue, saying that I truly believe he had the best interests of his constituents at heart, but that he simply was misinformed about buses. I hold a high standard for elected officials, and I strongly believe that Reid’s statements were entirely inappropriate and over the top.

  3. Joanna May 18, 2009 at 10:22 am #

    I’m so tired of grudges and egos keeping things from happening here in Oakland.

  4. Mark D. May 18, 2009 at 7:06 pm #

    All too sad when grudges get int he way of doing good work or Oakland. I hope he is able to get over his pettiness.

  5. munsonmunson June 5, 2009 at 12:02 pm #

    I have a question about New Urbanism and bicyclists that you might be able to help me with. Please check it out here: http://newurbanisminthenews.wordpress.com/2009/06/05/my-view-bicyclists-dont-worry-youre-in-the-gaines-plan/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: